VOSTRO 3460 : quelques doutes avant achat (+ suggestion ?) - Portable - Ordinateurs portables
Marsh Posté le 29-08-2012 à 13:06:38
J'ai un Vostro 3460. Je ferai un test ce soir en extérieur.
Après je suis pas une spécialiste, donc j'ai tendance à trouver l'écran et le matériel très bon.
Va faire un tour sur le forum Dell-Opération étudiant, t'auras peut-être plus de réponse: http://forum.hardware.fr/hfr/Ordin [...] 78.htm#bas
Marsh Posté le 29-08-2012 à 17:18:21
merci marion
je veux bien que tu me dise comment tu le trouve en exterieur (. .. pas trop tard le soir , le but etant de voir son comportement en plein soleil / lumiere forte
Marsh Posté le 30-08-2012 à 16:27:26
Y a pas de soleil en ce moment chez moi ^^
Mais pour les quelques jours de test de mon Vostro, l'écran est très satisfaisant. La datte est matte et j'ai donc aucun reflet
Marsh Posté le 31-08-2012 à 10:26:50
merci pour ton retour , c'est gentil de ta part.
je crois que je vais partir sur ce modèle , je ne trouve aucun équivalent prix / dimension / puissance
Marsh Posté le 31-08-2012 à 10:35:19
Franchement j'en suis vraiment satisfaite.
Je connais un équivalent c'est le MSI X460DX, mais il n'a pas un i5 de 3ème génération et pas les 3ans de garantie Dell pour étudiants.
Si t'as 100€ de plus à lâcher, prends un disque SSD 128Go, tu le mets à la place du disque dur. Et le HDD tu le mets à la place du graveur avec un Caddy (modèle Treasure TS06 sur ldlc ou materiel.net).
Je l'ai fait, tout marche nickel, et t'as un pc ultra rapide: démarrage en 15s, ouverture de Word instantanée
Marsh Posté le 31-08-2012 à 14:44:54
je l'avais pas vu celui là , effectivement ca reste quand meme moins interressant que le 3460 avec l'offre etudiant
merci pour le tuyau SSD je ferrais peut etre ca dans un second temps
merci de ton retour
Marsh Posté le 31-08-2012 à 19:58:11
Hello,
J'ai moi aussi un 3460, et j'en suis entièrement satisfait. Il passe très bien au soleil, il suffit juste de pousser un peu la luminosité. Peut etre les angles de vues qui ne sont pas fameux, mais sinon je le conseille.
Marsh Posté le 29-08-2012 à 12:05:03
Bonjour ,
je suis toujours en pleine etude de marché , le vostro 3460 etait en tete de liste mais j'ai une gros doute sur l'ecran
le test du 3360 sur notebookcheck http://www.notebookcheck.net/Revie [...] 737.0.html
+ un retour trouvé sur un forum semble d'accord sur la qualité de l'ecran assez faible
Re: Vostro 3460 Owner's Lounge
After having used it some more, I'll leave some more feedback and conclude my mini-review.
Performance:
Benchmark numbers are above. I have to say I'm really impressed with the Crucial M4, and that more than anything makes the system feel snappy. I've already blown through the meager 4GB of RAM (why does Firefox need 2GB?) and it hardly skips a beat despite paging constantly.
Design and Impression:
I think this is a very attractive laptop. The brushed aluminum is nice, and the Bronze color I have adds character without being gaudy. A lot of the corners and edges are well defined instead of rounded, and I actually prefer that. The entire inner surface is covered by a rubberized plastic, and it feels really nice to use. The fingerprint scanner actually works pretty well, and I find myself using it more and more out of convenience. There's a decent selection of ports, and I have no complaints about the layout.
Build Quality:
The chassis feels really well built. It's solid, sturdy, and resists torsion well. You can pick up the laptop by one corner and it still won't flex or creak.
The same unfortunately cannot be said about the screen lid. The screen flexes by a lot, and even opening the lid will cause the screen to flex noticeably. Furthermore the hinges are looser than I would prefer. I think Dell made the hinges just loose enough so you can open the lid with one hand, but the result is that the screen will wobble a lot. Even typing can wobble the screen.
Fit and finish is good but not great. There's still gaps here and there and some things don't quite line up, but those details are small and you'll unlikely notice or care unless you're really OCD about these things.
Screen:
Speaking of the screen, it's your typical bottom-of-the-line 1366x768 TN panel. Poor color, poor contrast, poor viewing angles, poor resolution; McKayla is definitely not impressed. Google AUO313C if you want to see some hard numbers. It's perfectly adequate for office use or web surfacing, but I'd avoid it for multimedia work or even watching movies. Also the bezel is rather big.
Keyboard and Touchpad:
The keyboard isn't bad but isn't great either. There's a fair amount of flex especially near the center. Feedback and response is decent, but typing still feels mushy or spongy. The biggest thing for me is that the keyboard feels a bit cramped. I measured keyboard and it's actually a bit shorter than the ones on my Vostro 2510 and unibody macbook 13, so the result is that I tend to overshoot bottom row keys and the spacebar. The response of the keys also becomes much worse when you hit the bottom edge. Maybe this is something I could get used to over time. Somehow Apple managed to fit a bigger keyboard and bigger trackpad into a smaller area.
On a positive note the layout I think is fantastic, especially with the navigation column on the right. For some reason I just can't get used to pgup and pgdn on the sides of the arrow keys, so this is appreciated.
The touchpad is similar quality. Accuracy could be better and I found there was a fair amount of tradeoff between speed and accuracy; I never could tune it to a point where tracking was both fast enough and accurate enough. The multitouch gestures work, but they feel really clumsy compared a mac. Overall I found myself relying more on the keyboard navigation column rather than gestures. Dell should really start using Synaptics instead of this Alps crap.
There's an FN combo to disable the touchpad when you're typing, so that's a nice plus.
Speakers:
I'm no audiophile, but it sounds decent to me until volume gets above about 50%. Then you start getting a lot of distortions and vibrations from the chassis.
The one thing I want to mention is that the speakers fire downwards, so having the laptop sit on a solid surface really helps.
Temps and Noise:
The temps are generally between 40's to 60's. The only concern I have is the HDD runs a bit warm due to its proximity to the heatsinks. Usually it's in the low to mid 40's, but it can easily spike to the 50's.
I'm not bothered at all by the fans, but they are rather aggressive. For me this is preferable to running a hot computer. I think you can change power settings so that it throttles the CPU before turning on the fans.
The only curiosity about noise is that the HDD is rather loud. I have a Seagate Momentus and it makes a pretty audible whirring noise when it's on. At first I mistook it for the fan.
Battery Life:
I didn't test this too much, but my estimates are 5-6 hours idle and 3-4 hours of light work or web browsing. Flash video will unsurprisingly eat through battery faster.
Conclusion:
Overall I'm pretty happy with it given what I paid. The biggest disappointment is by far the screen. Not just the panel, but the build quality of the lid as well. The keyboard, touchpad, speakers, and battery life are also not that great. At this price point though there's still going to be pretty big tradeoffs between performance, quality, and features and I think these are the areas where Dell really cut corners.
My usage generally involves a "docked" experience, so that mitigates most of the negatives for me. I'm quite happy with the performance and overall build quality. So far I also haven't had any issues with the hardware (my D1704 works great). At this point I don't see any reason to return it, although I still have almost two weeks left on that decision.
netbookcheck en vient meme à la conclusion qu'en utilisation exterieur malgrès la dalle "anti reflet" , le très faible taux de contrast ne permet pas une utilisation satisfaisante
The display’s matte surface ensures that the user will not be subjected to distracting reflections that would make outdoor use impossible, but the LED display’s low brightness falls short of ensuring the readability of screen contents in direct sunlight. As a result, users will likely need to find shade for many if not all outdoor tasks.
est ce que les possesseurs peuvent me faire un retour à ce sujet .
Je voulais trouver un portable utilisable en exterieur donc plutot dalle mate , mais peut etre que dans mon budget (600-800 €) , il faut mieux m'orienter vers un ecran glossy bien contrasté ?
Message édité par star_gust le 29-08-2012 à 14:08:33